Why counting stocks misleads
Take two portfolios, each with 10 stocks.
- Portfolio A has 10% in each stock.
- Portfolio B has 50% in one stock and about 5.6% in each of the other nine.
On a list they look the same. In real life they are not. If the big stock in B falls by a third, B loses about 17% even if the other nine hold still. The same fall in any one stock of A costs about 3%. B is mostly a bet on one company with nine small side bets.
The simple check: how many equal holdings do you act like?
This sum fixes the problem. You only need each holding's share of your money.
- Write each share as a decimal. 25% is 0.25.
- Square each one. 0.25 times 0.25 is 0.0625.
- Add up the squares.
- Divide 1 by that total.
The answer is how many equal-sized holdings your portfolio behaves like.
| Portfolio | Shares of money | Sum of squares | Acts like |
|---|---|---|---|
| A: 10 stocks | 10% each | 0.100 | 10 equal holdings |
| B: 10 stocks | 50%, then nine at about 5.6% | 0.278 | 3.6 equal holdings |
| C: 5 stocks | 40%, 30%, 15%, 10%, 5% | 0.285 | 3.5 equal holdings |
| D: 30 stocks | 40%, then 29 at about 2.1% | 0.172 | 5.8 equal holdings |
Portfolio D is the one to remember. Thirty names feels spread out, but with 40% in one stock it behaves like fewer than six. Economists call this number the inverse of the Herfindahl index. You only need to know that bigger is more spread out.
Where invest-like draws the lines
The portfolio report gives your spread one of three words:
- Well spread: 12 or more holdings, and none above 12% of the money.
- Somewhat concentrated: acts like at least 5 equal holdings, and the largest is under 30%.
- Concentrated: anything else.
It also writes the sentence for you, for example: "Your 10 holdings act like 3.6 equal ones; the largest, Company A, is 50%."
Then check the largest holding and the top three
The one sum hides who the big holdings are, so look at them by name. The report flags two cases:
- One holding at 25% or more. It tells you what a fall of a third would cost the whole portfolio. At 25% that is about 8%.
- Three holdings at 60% or more together (when you own more than three). Those three decide most of your result. The rest matter much less.
Check industries, not just companies
Five chip makers are not five separate bets. They sell to the same customers and have good and bad years together. So the report groups your money by sector and puts the share of each sector in the 500 largest US companies next to yours. When one sector holds 40% or more of your money (and you own more than two holdings), it says so: when that industry has a bad year, most of your portfolio has it too.
Countries and currencies
If you think in euros and own mostly US stocks, part of your result is the dollar. When the dollar weakens against the euro, your US shares are worth less to you even if their price does not move. The report shows your money by country and by currency, and flags it when 50% or more sits in currencies other than the one you chose for the report.
A note on funds
A broad index fund is already spread out inside. The portfolio report counts each fund as one holding and does not look inside it. So if most of your money is in broad funds, you are more spread out than the spread verdict shows. In that case, read the verdict as a check on the stocks you picked yourself.
Run the check on your own portfolio
You can do the sum in a spreadsheet in two minutes. Or paste your holdings into the free portfolio analyzer and get the spread check together with profit, growth, price and debt for the whole portfolio, weighted by money. For the full walk-through, see How to analyze your stock portfolio.