Comparison 1: the return
This is what most people mean by beating the market. Three rules make it fair:
- Same dates. Compare your return from a start date to an end date with the index over exactly those dates.
- Dividends on both sides. An S&P 500 fund paid about 1% a year in dividends. Compare total return with total return, or price with price.
- Money in and out. If you added money during the year, a simple "end value ÷ start value" overstates your return. Brokers usually show a time-weighted or money-weighted return that corrects for this.
One year proves little. A concentrated portfolio can beat the index by a lot in one year and trail it by more the next. Five years or more is a fairer test.
Comparison 2: what you own
A return tells you what happened. What you own tells you what you are betting on. The four numbers below are the ones invest-like's portfolio report sets next to the market. The market figures are the 500 largest US companies in its data, weighted by size, on 21 November 2026.
| What to compare | The market | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Price for $1 of yearly profit | about $28 | Paying much more than the market needs faster growth to work out. |
| Kept from $100 of sales | about $19 | How profitable your companies are. |
| Sales growth a year | 16.0% | Lifted by the very largest companies; the middle company grew 9.0%. |
| Dividend yield | 1.1% | The income your money produces each year. |
If your portfolio costs more per dollar of profit than the market, its companies need to grow faster than the market to justify it. If it costs less, check why: cheap is good only when the business is not shrinking.
Why the market's numbers lean on a few giants
Weighted by size, a handful of companies decide the market's figures. Apple, Nvidia, Microsoft, Alphabet and Amazon are worth more than all of the 300 smallest companies in the group together, so their fast growth and high margins pull the averages up. That is why the market's sales growth (16.0%) is far above the middle company's (9.0%). If you own mostly smaller companies, compare with the middle as well.