The higher the yield, the more often it is at risk
invest-like's dividend rule, applied to the 377 dividend payers among the 500 largest US companies on 20 November 2026 (looks safe: dividends under 60% of free cash flow and debt not heavy; at risk: above 90%, or heavy debt):
| Dividend yield | Companies | Looks safe | At risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Under 1% | 100 | 82 (82%) | 15 (15%) |
| 1% to 3% | 190 | 109 (57%) | 64 (34%) |
| 3% to 5% | 65 | 13 (20%) | 40 (62%) |
| 5% or more | 22 | 5 (23%) | 16 (73%) |
The rest of each row reads "watch it": dividends between 60% and 90% of free cash flow.
Why a high yield is often a warning
The yield is the yearly dividend divided by the share price. If the dividend stays the same and the price halves, the yield doubles. So a high yield often means the market has already marked the company down, usually because profits, sales or cash flow are shrinking. If the company then cuts the dividend, the investor who bought for the yield loses twice.
High yields, different stories
| Company | Yield | Paid out of free cash flow | Debt | Sales growth a year | Reading |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pfizer | 6.6% | 108% (2025) | Heavy (3.7 years) | 8.5% (2020 to 2025) | At risk |
| United Parcel Service | 6.2% | 113% (2025) | Manageable | 0.9% (2020 to 2025) | At risk |
| Kimberly-Clark | 5.2% | 101% (2025) | Manageable | -3.0% (2020 to 2025) | At risk |
| Verizon Communications | 5.8% | 58% (2025) | Heavy (3.4 years) | 1.5% (2020 to 2025) | At risk |
| Comcast | 5.3% | 25% (2025) | Manageable | 3.6% (2020 to 2025) | Looks safe |
| AT&T | 4.5% | 42% (2025) | Manageable | -2.6% (2020 to 2025) | Looks safe |
The pattern to look for: a dividend that takes all of the free cash flow or more while sales shrink, or a comfortable payout next to heavy debt. A high yield paid from a small part of the cash, with manageable debt, can simply mean the share price is low next to the company's cash flow. None of this says buy or sell; it shows what each yield rests on.
Three checks before you trust a high yield
- Cash: dividends under 60% of free cash flow.
- Debt: net debt under three years of operating earnings.
- Direction: sales flat or growing, not shrinking.
Also check for a one-time special dividend: it can make the trailing yield look far higher than the regular dividend. The full method is in how to check if a dividend is safe.