Buffett Brain · Research note
Score updated 22 Oct 2026 · analysis from 18 May 2026
AFG· Financial Services
American Financial Group
American Financial Group writes specialty P&C at a 12.7x multiple, but the 19% EPS decline cuts against the cheap optics.
Buffett fit
Weak fit
Owner
43
Durability
47
Management
41
Price
46
Score updated 22 Oct 2026 · analysis from 18 May 2026
Buffett's checklist
Each number against Buffett's bar, and where it ranks among Financial Services stocks in our database.
How much profit the business makes on each dollar invested in it. Higher is better.
What is left of each sale after the cost of making the product. A high number often means pricing power.
The cash the business earns for its owners, compared with the price of the whole company.
How fast sales grew each year over the last five years.
How many years of today's profit you pay for at today's price. Lower means cheaper.
How much the company owes compared with what it owns outright. Lower is safer.
The four pillars
How the business measures up on each of Buffett's four tests.
You would own a disciplined specialty insurer with an enviable long-term record but a deteriorating short-term one.
The full reasoning comes with a free account.
AFG has been profitable in all five recent years, a meaningful durability signal in cyclical insurance.
The full reasoning comes with a free account.
Share count has shrunk slightly at -0.4% CAGR, of 0.39 is modest, and /NI of 1.66 shows strong cash conversion.
The full reasoning comes with a free account.
At 12.7x trailing earnings and 10.8x EV/, the price screens cheap, and the 12.5% yield is genuinely attractive.
The full reasoning comes with a free account.
Free account
Read the full American Financial Group analysis free
- The full reasoning behind all four pillars
- Graham, Lynch and Greenblatt on the same stock
3 full analyses a week · no card needed
For and against
The strongest points on each side, with the numbers behind them.
In its favor
5- 112.5% yield is genuinely attractive at this multiple
- 212.7x and 10.8x EV/ screen as inexpensive
- 3/NI of 1.66 shows excellent cash conversion despite weak GAAP earnings
- 4Interest coverage of 13x and net debt/EBITDA of 0.37 keep the balance sheet sound
Concerns
4- 1TTM has crashed to 3.4% from a 16.8% five-year average
- 2EPS CAGR of -19.1% over five years signals deteriorating earnings power
- 3Peak-to-trough EPS decline of 55% is severe for a P&C insurer
- 4Specialty insurance is competitive and increasingly weather-loss exposed
Price history
$153+12.8%· 5-year return
Weekly closing prices. Touch or hover the line for a date.
The business
How the business works
American Financial Group is a specialty P&C insurance holding company writing in niche commercial lines like inland marine, agricultural, and specialty transportation. Underwriting is profitable with a 13.7% , and the float-driven model has historically delivered strong returns: five-year average of 16.8%. But the most recent year tells a different story, with TTM ROIC collapsing to 3.4% and EPS down 55% from its five-year peak. Specialty insurance is a competitive but underwriting-discipline-dependent niche, and AFG's recent results suggest pricing has softened.
What other investors would say
The same company, judged by three other documented playbooks.
Keep researching
Similar companies in Financial Services
Questions about American Financial Group
Free weekly email
Liked the read on AFG? Get the next ones on Monday.
Every Monday: the stocks most of the seven investors newly agree on. One email, unsubscribe any time.
Research, not investment advice.
See the Buffett analysis of American Financial Group
The score, the checklist and the full reasoning open with a free account. You get 3 full analyses a week, and this stock is the first one. No card needed.
Create a free account3 full analyses a week · no card needed
Already have an account? Sign in