What are the best consumer discretionary stocks for value investors?

Xenia Hotels & Resorts, Inc. (XHR) currently leads the consumer discretionary sector on the Joel Greenblatt framework with a composite score of 80/100, followed by FAST (75/100). The full ranked list of 25 consumer discretionary stocks indexed against the framework is on this page. Educational only, not investment advice.

Which consumer discretionary stock has the highest Buffett-Fit score?

According to invest-like.com, Xenia Hotels & Resorts, Inc. (XHR) currently has the highest Buffett-Fit composite score in the consumer discretionary sector at 80/100. invest-like.com's Buffett-Fit Score weighs five pillars (economic moat, earnings durability, management quality, financial health, and valuation) each on a 0-100 sub-scale, and refreshes the cached verdict on a 7-day TTL.

Is consumer discretionary a good sector for Joel Greenblatt-style investing?

The consumer discretionary sector's median quality score on invest-like.com is 54/100 with a median ROIC of 24%. Whether consumer discretionary is "good" for Joel Greenblatt-style investing depends on which sub-sectors and specific stocks you focus on: the framework's sector-relative scoring means stocks are graded against their own sector benchmarks, not a fixed cross-market hurdle.

Which consumer discretionary stocks have the best moats?

invest-like.com anchors moat strength in the Buffett-Fit framework on ROIC sustainability (above 15% sustained over multiple years) plus gross-margin durability (above 40% in industries where peers sit lower). The consumer discretionary sector's median ROIC on invest-like.com is 24%: the top-scoring stocks on this page are the ones with both quantitative moat anchors clearing the threshold AND qualitative moat sources (brand, switching costs, network effects, regulatory).

How many consumer discretionary stocks does invest-like.com cover?

invest-like.com currently indexes 25 consumer discretionary stocks above $500M market cap with cached verdicts on the Buffett-Fit framework. invest-like.com scores each stock from 0 to 100, with sub-scores for moat, durability, management, financial health, and valuation. The full ranked list is on this page.

Is the consumer discretionary ranking on this page investment advice?

No. invest-like.com publishes the ranking as an educational pattern-match against documented value-investing frameworks (Buffett, Graham, Fisher, Lynch, Greenblatt, Munger, Smith). invest-like.com's scores reflect how closely each stock fits the documented criteria: they are NOT recommendations to buy, hold, or sell. Always do your own research and consult a licensed financial adviser for personalised investment advice.

Consumer Discretionary · Joel Greenblatt fit

Best Consumer Discretionary Stocks for Joel Greenblatt Investors

Top 25 consumer discretionary stocks ranked by their Joel Greenblatt fit score, every score computed from current financials against published criteria. Updated daily.

How We Rank These

Each stock is scored on a 0–100 scale across the Joel Greenblatt criteria (moat, durability, valuation, financial health, capital allocation). The score is a deterministic function of the company's TTM financials, no opinion, no hand-tuning. Rows with insufficient data are excluded.

The Top 25

#1
80/100
XHRXenia Hotels & Resorts, Inc.80/100
High-quality business at a cheap price - strong Magic Formula fit.
Mkt cap
$2.05B
ROIC
70.56%
#2
75/100
FASTFastenal Company75/100
High-quality business at a cheap price, strong Magic Formula fit.
Mkt cap
$59.03B
ROIC
28.76%
#3
69/100
WINAWinmark Corporation69/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$1.01B
ROIC
2.43%
#4
68/100
ORLYO'Reilly Automotive, Inc.68/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$73.16B
ROIC
34.07%
#5
63/100
COSTCostco Wholesale Corporation63/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$435.48B
ROIC
23.8%
#6
63/100
YUMYum! Brands, Inc.63/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$40.98B
ROIC
31.39%
#7
61/100
RSIRush Street Interactive, Inc.61/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$3.5B
ROIC
24.78%
#8
61/100
GTXGarrett Motion Inc.61/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$4.18B
ROIC
42.85%
#9
59/100
CHWYChewy, Inc.59/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$8.3B
ROIC
20.11%
#10
59/100
HLTHilton Worldwide Holdings Inc.59/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$77.79B
ROIC
16.89%
#11
56/100
ROSTRoss Stores, Inc.56/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$72.83B
ROIC
20.46%
#12
55/100
MARMarriott International, Inc.55/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$102.85B
ROIC
15.35%
#13
54/100
CMGChipotle Mexican Grill, Inc.54/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$36.36B
ROIC
18.46%
#14
54/100
WINGWingstop Inc.54/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$3.77B
ROIC
25.92%
#15
54/100
TJXThe TJX Companies, Inc.54/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$152.88B
ROIC
25.22%
#16
54/100
AMZNAmazon.com, Inc.54/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$2.75T
ROIC
14.3%
#17
54/100
AZOAutoZone, Inc.54/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$50.81B
ROIC
25.93%
#18
52/100
DECKDeckers Outdoor Corporation52/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$11B
ROIC
32.7%
#19
52/100
SHWThe Sherwin-Williams Company52/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$77.5B
ROIC
17.56%
#20
52/100
MCDMcDonald's Corporation52/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$177.26B
ROIC
19.06%
#21
52/100
SBUXStarbucks Corporation52/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$117.65B
ROIC
13.34%
#22
51/100
WSMWilliams-Sonoma, Inc.51/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$29.45B
ROIC
28.83%
#23
51/100
WMTWalmart Inc.51/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$942.29B
ROIC
15.68%
#24
50/100
BALYBally's Corporation50/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$679.82M
ROIC
-0.05%
#25
50/100
TXRHTexas Roadhouse, Inc.50/100
Partial match: either cheap or high-quality, but not both.
Mkt cap
$11.47B
ROIC
15.34%

Same Sector, Other Strategies

Best Consumer Discretionary for Warren Buffett Best Consumer Discretionary for Benjamin Graham Best Consumer Discretionary for Peter Lynch