MTG
Is MGIC Investment Corporation's (MTG) dividend safe?
MGIC Investment Corporation (MTG) currently pays a dividend yield of 2.3% with an FCF payout ratio of 18.6%. Dividend safety isn't about the yield - high yields often signal stress - it's about whether free cash flow comfortably covers the payment. The full coverage analysis is below. Educational only, not investment advice.
FCF payout coverage. MGIC Investment Corporation's free-cash-flow payout ratio is n/a. Below 60% is comfortable - the business is keeping at least 40% of cash for reinvestment, debt reduction, or buybacks. Between 60-90% is workable but tighter; above 90% leaves no buffer, which is where dividend cuts become a real risk during a downturn.
Earnings vs FCF. The traditional payout ratio (dividends / earnings) sits at 18.6%. Compared against the FCF payout ratio above, large gaps indicate one of two things: accounting earnings being inflated by non-cash items (FCF payout much higher than earnings payout - red flag) or aggressive cash management lifting near-term FCF (FCF payout much lower than earnings payout - sometimes a sign of working-capital releases that won't repeat).
Growth track record. MGIC Investment Corporation's 5-year dividend CAGR is 8.9%. Consistent growth across at least one downturn is the gold standard - it means management treats the dividend as a commitment, not a discretionary outflow. A 5-year track record without a cut during the last recession is much stronger evidence than a high current yield.
How invest-like measures this
Dividend safety isn't about the yield - a high yield often signals stress. It's about coverage: does free cash flow comfortably cover the dividend with room to spare? The invest-like dividend-safety score weighs three signals: FCF payout ratio (under 60% is comfortable; over 90% is fragile), earnings payout ratio (less reliable than FCF because accruals can mask cash shortfalls), and dividend growth track record (consistent 5-year CAGR vs cuts during the last downturn).
Educational only - even an A-rated dividend can be cut tomorrow by a single board decision. We're measuring documented financial capacity to maintain the payout, not predicting management intent.
More questions about MTG
Dive deeper into MTG
Related on invest-like
Educational framework analysis only. Not investment advice, not a recommendation, not personalized to your situation. Always do your own research.