Below 2% - growth-tilted
The company reinvests or buys back stock. Total return comes from price appreciation, not income.
Benchmark
What is a good dividend yield?
A good dividend yield is generally in the 2-5% range - high enough to deliver real income, low enough to be sustainable. Below 2% is typical of growth-tilted compounders that reinvest instead of paying out; above 6% is often a warning sign that the market expects a cut. The healthiest signal isn't the highest yield - it's a moderate yield backed by a comfortable payout ratio and a record of dividend growth.
Last reviewed:
Short answer
2-5% is the sweet spot. Chasing the highest yield is the classic income-investor trap - a 9% yield usually means the price collapsed because the market expects a cut. A growing 3% beats a fragile 7%.
How to read a dividend yield
2-4% - balanced
Sustainable income from a mature, profitable payer. The sweet spot for most dividend investors.
4-6% - high income
Attractive income - if the payout ratio is comfortable and earnings clearly cover the dividend.
Above 6% - check the safety
Often a yield trap: a falling price bracing for a cut. Verify with the payout ratio and cash flow.
Why the highest yield is rarely the best
Stock A yields 7 percent but pays out 95 percent of earnings and hasn't raised its dividend in years - one bad quarter forces a cut. Stock B yields 3 percent, pays out 45 percent, and has grown its dividend 8 percent a year for a decade. In five years, B's income on your original cost may exceed A's, with far less risk of a cut.
That's the core lesson: yield is a snapshot, sustainability is the story. Always read the dividend yield next to the payout ratio (how much of earnings goes out) and the dividend-growth record.
The Consensus - free weekly screen
Every Monday: the stocks that newly pass 5 or more of the 7 legendary-investor frameworks (Buffett, Graham, Lynch, Greenblatt, Munger, Fisher, Smith), plus every grade change that matters. The 5-year track record of this screen is published openly. One email a week, unsubscribe anytime.
Related
- What is dividend yield? - the definition and formula behind this benchmark.
- What is the payout ratio? - the single best check on whether a yield is safe.
- What is a dividend aristocrat? - 25+ years of consecutive increases - durability over headline yield.
- Best dividend growth stocks 2026 - the live ranking of durable, growing payers screened on coverage.
Judge income on durability, not just yield
invest-like shows dividend yield with the payout ratio, free cash flow, and dividend growth on every payer, so a fat yield can't hide a fragile dividend.
Educational only. invest-like is not a registered investment adviser; nothing here is personalised investment advice. Always do your own research and consider your individual circumstances.