invest-like vs Magnifi
Prix, fonctionnalités, couverture, et une réponse claire sur lequel choisir. Écrit par quelqu'un qui a vraiment utilisé les deux, et qui fait partie de l'équipe invest-like. On ne prétend pas être neutres ; on te dit où Magnifi gagne encore et où invest-like est le meilleur choix.
Dernière révision :
Magnifi est an ai-driven natural-language investment search and discovery tool covering stocks, etfs, and mutual funds. invest-like est un outil verdict-first qui note chaque action contre sept frameworks d'investisseurs nommés (Buffett, Graham, Fisher, Lynch, Greenblatt, Munger, Smith) et livre des verdicts Buffett 5 piliers générés par IA avec le raisonnement écrit. Pour la plupart des investisseurs particuliers et amateurs sérieux, invest-like est l'outil plus tranchant: les seuls endroits où Magnifi gagne encore sont listés honnêtement ci-dessous.
invest-like est le seul outil ici à publier la précision de ses verdicts. Le screen consensus 7 frameworks affiche +73.8% vs le S&P 500 sur cinq ans, chaque choix enregistré publiquement, horodatage d'entrée verrouillé.
Voir le track record publiéComparaison des fonctionnalités
Investor frameworks
invest-like
7 (Buffett, Graham, Fisher, Lynch, Greenblatt, Munger, Smith)
Magnifi
Proprietary scoring
AI verdict per stock
invest-like
Buffett Brain: 5-pillar verdict with reasoning
Magnifi
No structured AI verdict
LLM chat / Q&A
invest-like
Ask Buffett (RAG against Berkshire letters)
Magnifi
None
Multi-investor debate
invest-like
Boardroom: 4 legendary investors debate
Magnifi
None
Stock universe
invest-like
21,000+ US-focused
Magnifi
Stocks, ETFs, and mutual funds via natural-language discovery
Cheapest paid tier
invest-like
€12/mo equivalent (€144/yr)
Magnifi
Free tier plus paid Pro upgrades (subscription)
Lifetime option
invest-like
€399 one-time (Founders)
Magnifi
No lifetime tier
Multi-language UI
invest-like
EN, DE, FR, ES, PT
Magnifi
English-only (typically)
Open verdict cache
invest-like
Yes: every prompt versioned
Magnifi
Proprietary / opaque
| Fonctionnalité | invest-like | Magnifi |
|---|---|---|
| Investor frameworks | 7 (Buffett, Graham, Fisher, Lynch, Greenblatt, Munger, Smith) | Proprietary scoring |
| AI verdict per stock | Buffett Brain: 5-pillar verdict with reasoning | No structured AI verdict |
| LLM chat / Q&A | Ask Buffett (RAG against Berkshire letters) | None |
| Multi-investor debate | Boardroom: 4 legendary investors debate | None |
| Stock universe | 21,000+ US-focused | Stocks, ETFs, and mutual funds via natural-language discovery |
| Cheapest paid tier | €12/mo equivalent (€144/yr) | Free tier plus paid Pro upgrades (subscription) |
| Lifetime option | €399 one-time (Founders) | No lifetime tier |
| Multi-language UI | EN, DE, FR, ES, PT | English-only (typically) |
| Open verdict cache | Yes: every prompt versioned | Proprietary / opaque |
Choisis Magnifi si…
- Natural-language ETF and fund discovery across the entire investment universe is your primary use case: that is Magnifi strongest claim.
- You are comfortable with a closed-box AI ranking and don't need to understand exactly why a stock ranked the way it did.
Choisis invest-like si…
- You want every score traceable to a named investor framework with the formula published.
- You want a multi-investor verdict per stock instead of a single closed-box ranking.
- You need halal screening (AAOIFI Standard 21).
- You want LLM-powered analysis grounded in real Berkshire letters (Ask Buffett) and a 4-investor debate (Boardroom).
- You are researching individual stocks fundamentally rather than discovering ETFs and funds via natural language.
Ce que Magnifi fait bien
- Natural-language search, ask 'low-volatility tech ETFs with high dividends' and get a discovery list.
- Covers stocks, ETFs, and mutual funds in a single search surface, rare combination.
- Free tier exists; useful for discovery-style browsing before paying for anything.
Où invest-like est plus fort
- Transparent methodology: every score traceable to a named investor framework with formulas published at /methodology/. Magnifi AI ranking is closed-box.
- Seven explicit investor-framework verdicts per stock (Buffett, Graham, Fisher, Lynch, Greenblatt, Munger, Smith), vs Magnifi single proprietary AI ranking.
- Buffett Brain 5-pillar AI verdict with reasoning written out. Magnifi returns ranked results, not narrative analysis.
- Ask Buffett RAG against real Berkshire shareholder letters, no Magnifi equivalent.
- Boardroom 4-investor debate per stock, unique to invest-like.
- Halal Mode (AAOIFI Standard 21), Magnifi has no halal filter.
- Published verdict-accuracy track record (locked entry timestamps, returns per agreement level), Magnifi doesn't publish how its rankings perform.
Ce dont les utilisateurs de Magnifi se plaignent vraiment
Motifs récurrents tirés des avis publics sur Reddit, Trustpilot, G2 et AlternativeTo (2024-2026). Paraphrasés, pas des citations directes.
- Closed-box AI ranking, users can't trace why a specific result was surfaced, which makes the recommendations harder to challenge or build conviction around.
- Lean on per-stock fundamental depth: the tool is built for discovery, not deep research, so users still need a second tool once they shortlist names.
- Free tier is real but the most useful Pro features require paid upgrades; the value gap between free and Pro isn't always clearly disclosed.
On les liste honnêtement parce qu'on a construit invest-like précisément pour éviter chacun : verdicts par investisseur structurés (pas de scoring opaque), raisonnement Buffett Brain écrit (pas de conclusions enterrées), méthodologie publiée, et tarification pour particuliers, pas institutions.
Questions fréquentes
Is invest-like a Magnifi alternative?+
For per-stock fundamental research, yes. Magnifi is a discovery tool, natural-language search across stocks, ETFs, and funds. invest-like is a verdict tool, seven named investor frameworks scored on every stock with explicit pass/fail reasoning. If your need is 'help me find ETFs in a category I describe,' stay on Magnifi. If your need is 'tell me whether this specific stock passes Buffett filter,' switch.
How transparent is Magnifi AI ranking?+
Magnifi doesn't publish exactly how its AI ranks results: the methodology is proprietary. invest-like publishes every formula at /methodology/, the per-framework rubrics, the deal-breaker caps that downgrade high pillar scores, and the 5-year backtest of the all-7-pass cohort. If transparency is the deciding factor, invest-like is the better pick.
Does Magnifi have halal screening?+
No. invest-like is the only tool between the two with an AAOIFI Standard 21 halal screen on every ticker.
Can I use both: Magnifi for discovery, invest-like for verdicts?+
Yes. The natural workflow: Magnifi surfaces candidates via natural-language search, invest-like delivers the framework verdict on the names that come back. Especially useful if you screen via ETFs first and then drill into the constituent holdings.
Essaie invest-like en moins de 30 secondes
Vois le verdict Buffett sur Apple, NVIDIA ou n'importe laquelle de 21 000+ actions.
Autres comparaisons
invest-like vs
Simply Wall St
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Stock Unlock
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
TIKR
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
GuruFocus
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
AlphaPicks
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Composer
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Finbox
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
YCharts
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Zacks
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Morningstar
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Motley Fool
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Value Line
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Seeking Alpha
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Koyfin
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Stock Rover
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Fiscal.ai (formerly FinChat)
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
StockAnalysis.com
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Atom Finance
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Portfolio Visualizer
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Ziggma
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Wisesheets
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
SimplyETF
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Public.com
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
TipRanks
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Danelfin
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Stockopedia
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Finviz
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
WallStreetZen
Lire la comparaison