invest-like vs Public.com
Prix, fonctionnalités, couverture, et une réponse claire sur lequel choisir. Écrit par quelqu'un qui a vraiment utilisé les deux, et qui fait partie de l'équipe invest-like. On ne prétend pas être neutres ; on te dit où Public.com gagne encore et où invest-like est le meilleur choix.
Dernière révision :
Public.com est a us brokerage with built-in fractional shares, social investing features, and ai-assisted commentary on individual tickers. invest-like est un outil verdict-first qui note chaque action contre sept frameworks d'investisseurs nommés (Buffett, Graham, Fisher, Lynch, Greenblatt, Munger, Smith) et livre des verdicts Buffett 5 piliers générés par IA avec le raisonnement écrit. Pour la plupart des investisseurs particuliers et amateurs sérieux, invest-like est l'outil plus tranchant: les seuls endroits où Public.com gagne encore sont listés honnêtement ci-dessous.
invest-like est le seul outil ici à publier la précision de ses verdicts. Le screen consensus 7 frameworks affiche +73.8% vs le S&P 500 sur cinq ans, chaque choix enregistré publiquement, horodatage d'entrée verrouillé.
Voir le track record publiéComparaison des fonctionnalités
Investor frameworks
invest-like
7 (Buffett, Graham, Fisher, Lynch, Greenblatt, Munger, Smith)
Public.com
Proprietary scoring
AI verdict per stock
invest-like
Buffett Brain: 5-pillar verdict with reasoning
Public.com
No structured AI verdict
LLM chat / Q&A
invest-like
Ask Buffett (RAG against Berkshire letters)
Public.com
None
Multi-investor debate
invest-like
Boardroom: 4 legendary investors debate
Public.com
None
Stock universe
invest-like
21,000+ US-focused
Public.com
US-listed stocks, ETFs, crypto, treasuries, alternative assets
Cheapest paid tier
invest-like
€12/mo equivalent (€144/yr)
Public.com
Free brokerage; optional Public Premium ~$8/mo for advanced features
Lifetime option
invest-like
€399 one-time (Founders)
Public.com
No lifetime tier
Multi-language UI
invest-like
EN, DE, FR, ES, PT
Public.com
English-only (typically)
Open verdict cache
invest-like
Yes: every prompt versioned
Public.com
Proprietary / opaque
| Fonctionnalité | invest-like | Public.com |
|---|---|---|
| Investor frameworks | 7 (Buffett, Graham, Fisher, Lynch, Greenblatt, Munger, Smith) | Proprietary scoring |
| AI verdict per stock | Buffett Brain: 5-pillar verdict with reasoning | No structured AI verdict |
| LLM chat / Q&A | Ask Buffett (RAG against Berkshire letters) | None |
| Multi-investor debate | Boardroom: 4 legendary investors debate | None |
| Stock universe | 21,000+ US-focused | US-listed stocks, ETFs, crypto, treasuries, alternative assets |
| Cheapest paid tier | €12/mo equivalent (€144/yr) | Free brokerage; optional Public Premium ~$8/mo for advanced features |
| Lifetime option | €399 one-time (Founders) | No lifetime tier |
| Multi-language UI | EN, DE, FR, ES, PT | English-only (typically) |
| Open verdict cache | Yes: every prompt versioned | Proprietary / opaque |
Choisis Public.com si…
- You want a single app for execution + light research and don't mind that the AI commentary is conversational rather than framework-grounded.
- Fractional shares + social-investing features + alternative-asset access are your primary needs.
Choisis invest-like si…
- You want framework-grounded verdicts, not conversational AI commentary inside a brokerage.
- You want research with no brokerage execution conflict.
- You want multi-investor framework consensus, not a single AI take.
- You need halal screening.
Ce que Public.com fait bien
- Integrated brokerage execution + research in one app.
- Fractional shares + social-investing features for retail engagement.
- Recently added AI-assisted commentary on individual tickers (Alpha by Public).
Où invest-like est plus fort
- Seven explicit named investor frameworks per stock with structured pass/fail reasoning, Public.com's AI commentary is conversational, not framework-grounded.
- Buffett Brain delivers a structured 5-pillar verdict, Public.com Alpha generates prose commentary without a structured verdict shape.
- Ask Buffett RAG-grounded against verbatim Berkshire shareholder letters, Public.com's AI is not grounded in named investor primary sources.
- Boardroom 4-investor live debate, unique.
- Halal Mode (AAOIFI Standard 21), Public.com does not ship halal screening.
- Published verdict-accuracy track record with locked entry timestamps, Public.com does not publish AI commentary accuracy.
- invest-like is research-only with no brokerage conflict, Public.com's AI exists inside a brokerage that profits from your trades.
Ce dont les utilisateurs de Public.com se plaignent vraiment
Motifs récurrents tirés des avis publics sur Reddit, Trustpilot, G2 et AlternativeTo (2024-2026). Paraphrasés, pas des citations directes.
- AI commentary is conversational and prose-style; users wanting structured verdicts go elsewhere.
- Brokerage UI mixes research and execution in ways some users find distracting.
- Free tier features behind Premium gates on advanced screens.
On les liste honnêtement parce qu'on a construit invest-like précisément pour éviter chacun : verdicts par investisseur structurés (pas de scoring opaque), raisonnement Buffett Brain écrit (pas de conclusions enterrées), méthodologie publiée, et tarification pour particuliers, pas institutions.
Questions fréquentes
Is invest-like a Public.com alternative?+
Different layers. Public.com is a brokerage with research bolted on; invest-like is a research-only platform that works alongside any brokerage. Our suggestion: keep your brokerage account (Public.com, Robinhood, Fidelity, IBKR, whichever) and use invest-like for the verdict layer.
Is Public.com's Alpha AI better than Buffett Brain?+
Different products. Alpha generates conversational commentary on individual tickers; Buffett Brain delivers a structured 5-pillar verdict (moat, durability, management, financial health, valuation) with reasoning per pillar plus the six other framework scores. Alpha is conversational; Buffett Brain is structured.
Does invest-like execute trades?+
No. invest-like is research-only with no brokerage relationship. You use whatever brokerage you already have (Public.com, Schwab, Fidelity, IBKR, etc.) for execution. The benefit: no broker-revenue conflict of interest in the research layer.
Does Public.com screen for halal stocks?+
No, not as a first-class feature. invest-like ships AAOIFI Standard 21 on every ticker with a working paper backing the methodology.
Essaie invest-like en moins de 30 secondes
Vois le verdict Buffett sur Apple, NVIDIA ou n'importe laquelle de 21 000+ actions.
Autres comparaisons
invest-like vs
Simply Wall St
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Stock Unlock
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
TIKR
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
GuruFocus
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
AlphaPicks
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Composer
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Finbox
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Magnifi
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
YCharts
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Zacks
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Morningstar
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Motley Fool
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Value Line
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Seeking Alpha
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Koyfin
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Stock Rover
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Fiscal.ai (formerly FinChat)
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
StockAnalysis.com
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Atom Finance
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Portfolio Visualizer
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Ziggma
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Wisesheets
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
SimplyETF
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
TipRanks
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Danelfin
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Stockopedia
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
Finviz
Lire la comparaisoninvest-like vs
WallStreetZen
Lire la comparaison